3 Best Dog Poop Bag Holders (For Used Bags, Not Just Dispensers)

Every dog owner knows (or should know) about poop bag dispensers. They solve half of a problem. The other half is what to do with the used bags? That’s the messy part nobody tells you about, and it’s this part that dog poop bag holders or carriers help. 

Ask yourself this: 

When was the most annoying time you had to carry a used bag on your walk? 

I can tell you of a couple of scenarios that come to mind:

One time, I was walking through the park, both dogs stopped and did their business at the same time. I tethered them to a lamp post, bagged the mess, got the dogs, walked back toward the nearest bin that was right beside a park bench with people sitting on it, and lo-and-behold, the bin was overflowing. I had to walk into a busy area with two dogs and a few full poop bags swinging around until I found a bin. 

Another time, I found myself on a holiday park, pitch dark at night, skips as bins at the end of roads (not exactly nearby), and the rain was bouncing off the ground. Here I was juggling two leads, a torch, and poop bags swinging from the leads in the rain. 

Now, if you don’t know, on holiday parks, you don’t have a wheelie bin by your door. Returning to base with used bags isn’t an option, and that’s exactly the sort of situations these used dog poop bag holders become extremely handy.  

The 3 Dog Poop Bag Holders and Carriers You Ought to Know About

➔ 1. The Doo-Kee Used Poo Bag Holder

Pros:

• Designed for ultimate convenience; “knot it and slot it”
• Used by professional dog walkers – we all know they walk with packs! 
• Eco-friendly brand and these are made in the UK!

Cons:

• Clip supplied fits standard leads only – not Flexi types, though I’m no fan of extending leads anyway.
• Users have experienced issues with clips breaking – so I’d suggest using a stronger carabiner clip, like those designed for outdoor adventures. 

My Take

The sheer simplicity of the Doo-Kee makes it hard to believe that it’s a relatively new concept. These are made with PLA (Polylactic acid), a type of renewable material made from plant-based resources like corn starch, and sugarcane. It’s commonly used in 3D printing. 

The quality of the printed holder is uncontested. What is, judging by user reviews, is the strength of the clip. My guess is that it’s a 3rd party supplier and for anything being attached to dog walking bags, leads, or even harnesses, I’d always suggest going with a tough steel carabiner clip because outdoors, things are always going to be knocked around. 

Find the latest deals on the Doo-Kee here

➔ 2. The Original Dicky Bag

Pros:

• Available in multiple sizes: perfect for multi-dog households.
• Numerous ways to carry it and each is hands free.
• Machine washable on a 30^oC cycle. 

Cons:

• It’s a little misleading to describe it as odour-free. It’s really for discreet carrying while walking until you get to a public bin, not really for in the car. Once the heat hits, it’s going to be foul! 
• It is pricey for an accessory, though it is sturdy and should last for years.

My take: 

Don’t let the images of the bag beside a tennis ball confuse you. It’s there to illustrate the size of the bag. XL Dicky bags are 18cm x 11cm so a good size for a couple of Staffies or medium-sized breeds. I’ve read user reviews from people who walk four dogs at a time, and this carries the lot!

Inside are a couple of neat additions. 

1. The fragrance disc. It might not completely eradicate odour, but it sure can help diffuse it. 

2. There’s an integrated bag dispenser. Everything you need is neatly handled in one convenient accessory and it can be fastened easily to any of the many styles of dog walking bags. 

Get the latest deals on the Original Dicky Bag here. 

Fun Fact: This is another UK brand, and the name uses Cockney rhyming slang to create a discreet name for a product that’s designed to be discreet.  

➔ 3. MuKi Life Dog Walking Waste Carrier

Pros:

• Removable liner for washing.
• Convenient outer pocket for carrying hand sanitiser (or little niknaks).
• Waterproof fabric and zipper.

Cons:

• A little heavier than the Dicky Bag and smaller since it’s designed with a removable insert for washing.
• Only available in one size and is suited to small to medium breeds. 

My take: 

I like the owner’s story. They’re campers. Explorers. UK-too. Are you spotting a theme yet? Yes, in Britain, dog walkers who enjoy the trails, do our bit to respect the space, leave no trace, and carry the mess until we find a bin. 

The Muki Life portable dog bin isn’t just for campers though. It’s ideal for any trail-treks, on holiday parks, or even the local park when you just want to carry on with your walk without having to double back to a bin you passed, but continue until the next one. The fact this is waterproof too helps, because you won’t be caught off guard in a downpour. 

Get the latest deals on the Muki Life bag here

A Quick Guide to Dog Poop Bag Holders/Carriers

Like most things for adventures with your dog, there’s different things for different needs. Here’s what I find to be factors to help distinguish between the different styles and types. 

Weather-proofness

Given the UK weather, every accessory that goes on walks needs to be able to withstand the wet. All 3 of these do, some better than others. The simplest is the knot it and slot it Doo-Kee attachment, but the downside to that is the clip isn’t the toughest. Upgrade that and you’re onto an all-weather winner. The pricier workaround is the weather-resistant Dicky Bag or MukiLife portable dog poop carrier. 

Odour-resistance

A sealed bag holder is better than a carrier attachment for masking scents. This is of particular concern to those of you who are noticing the disappearance of bins on walking routes. If you drive to a favourite walking spot, you’ll want something that’s as odour-free as possible. The Dicky Bag with the fragranced discs, or the Muki-Life bag for small to medium sized dogs. 

Sizing

For dog walkers or those with more than 2 dogs, the largest capacity will be a few of the cheaper Doo-Kee carriers. Knot the bags, slot it into the holder and carry on. Each can carry a few used poop bags, hence why professional dog walkers seem to be the most common reviewers. They need this type of large capacity carrier. 

… and the Carrying Style 

For regular walking, the Doo-Kee is handy for around the block walks. For those trekking further afield on trails, or rocky footpaths, or on rough terrain, the long strap on the Muki Life portable dog poop bag holder is handy for wearing around the waist or over your shoulder. For regular walks on trails, or level surfaces where there’s likelihood of clips being damaged, the Dicky Bag fits the bill best with it’s sturdy metal clip attachment. 

Wrapping Things Up: 

It makes me proud to see British brands come up with these handy gadgets that make walking more pleasant. I find it so frustrating on trails when someone takes the care to bag the mess, then undoes the good by tossing the bag up in a tree, into the long grass, or just leaves it. To an extent, I think they believe biodegradable bags somehow disappear like magic. 

For those of us who know different and do our bit to keep our trails clean even when the councils have removed litter bins, dog poop bag holders or carriers provide a solution that helps us enjoy our walks, despite inconveniences. For the budget option, the Doo-Kee is the no-brainer. For all-weather dog walks, both the Dicky Bag and Muki Life bag, which although pricier, are designed to last much longer, and are washable. 

Personal choice: If I had to pick just one for daily use, it’d be the Doo-Kee. It’s cheap enough to replace and I’m forever breaking attachments or losing things on hikes. 

For more info, the latest prices, and user reviews, use the links below:

FAQs