The 3 Best Durable Dog Toys For Aggressive Chewers

If you’re at your wit’s end, convinced that “tough chew” labels are some kind of cruel joke, and just hoping to find a toy that’ll still be in one piece by morning—you’re in luck. I know of a few that actually hold up!

With two Staffies who take “aggressive chewers” to a whole new level, I know firsthand how frustrating it is when toys barely last a day. Truth is, most so-called durable toys don’t stand a chance against a determined dog with powerful jaws. After trying countless options, only a handful have truly stood the test of time. (And some of those, not as well as expected)

Now, no toy is truly indestructible, but depending on what you need, these are the best of the best:

Let’s start with the toughest one of all…

1. The Benebone Indestructible Wishbone

Is it the shape? The material? Honestly, I’m not sure. What I do know is that the Benebone Indestructible Chew Toy gets put through its paces every single morning—and it holds up.

It’s one of the few tough chews I’m actually comfortable letting my dogs play with unsupervised in the garden. And that’s saying something.

Tough Enough for Tug? Yep.

Our two Staffies don’t just chew—they battle over toys. They play tug-of-war like it’s a professional sport, and somehow, the Benebone (along with a couple of others I’ll get to) has survived the full-force tugging of two determined Staffies.

Do the Flavours Matter?

Not really. We’ve gave them beef, chicken, bacon—you name it. They seem to love them all. The only ones they haven’t tested are peanut butter and, not being in the U.S., the pumpkin-flavoured version. But let’s be honest: The flavour is just on the surface, not throughout. After the first good chew session, that’ll be pretty much gone.

What Makes It Worth It?

Durable nylon. That’s the game-changer. It’s sturdy enough to last for months, but like any chew toy, it will eventually need replacing. After enough gnawing, you’ll start to see (and feel when you’re picking up after them) sharp nylon shards forming—that’s when it’s time for a new one.

Key Features:

• Made from tough, flavour infused nylon – Built to withstand aggressive chewing.
• Available in multiple flavours and sizes – Something for every dog’s preference.
• Long-lasting – Holds up for months, even with daily use.

Considerations:

• Not meant for consumption – This is a chew toy, not an edible treat. Always monitor for wear and replace when needed.
• Can develop sharp edges over time – After prolonged chewing, the nylon can form rough or pointy spots. Swap it out when this happens.

Say goodbye to toys that fall apart! The Benebone is designed to stand up to tough chewers.
Check out the Benebone on Amazon!

Next up, is…

2. The KONG Extreme

The KONG Extreme is definitely one of the best toys for power chewers, but there’s a catch: You need to buy the right size for your dog. And trust me, it’s not the size the KONG size guide suggests.

You’ll want to go with the next size up, which they even mention on their site, “it’s always best to size up“, yet, don’t state that on the product listing. I honestly don’t get why they don’t just update the chart to show the larger size as the recommended one.

When we first tried it, I made the mistake of buying the wrong size AND the wrong type. Classic KONG, instead of the Puppy KONG. One of the dogs started to widen the hole, and if you’ve got a serious chewer, you know that’s game over. Once they get a start, they’re determined to take the thing apart.

Why It’s a Strong Contender:

Despite the sizing issue, the KONG Extreme holds its ground as one of the toughest chew toys out there. Its ultra-durable rubber construction has withstood the jaws of countless dogs labeled as power chewers, making it a top choice alongside the Benebone.

The KONG brand has plenty of dog toys, but only the KONG Extreme features the toughest rubber, made for aggressive chewers—if you get the right size.

After watching my dogs go through countless toys, I figured the KONG Classic would be indestructible. But when the hole got big enough, they started pulling and tearing it apart. I should’ve gone with the KONG Extreme in a better suited size. It was a pricey mistake, and I never replaced it, but now I know: always pay close attention to the size guide when buying a KONG.

Now, as for that hole at the base of the Extreme, that’s where things get interesting. People have found creative ways to use this. Some put in small treats, turning it into a type of puzzle toy for dogs, others fill it with peanut butter, pop it in the freezer then give it to the dog as a type of flavoured licky toy.

Ultimately, its durability comes down to your dog’s chewing habits and choosing the right size.

Key Features:

• Made from extra-durable rubber – Built to last against determined destructive chewing.
• Stuffable with treats – Keeps your dog mentally engaged and entertained.
• Erratic bounce – Adds an extra layer of fun to playtime.

Considerations:

• Size matters! – Choosing the wrong size can lead to faster wear and tear.
• Focus on the hollow centre – Some dogs may concentrate on this area, weakening the toy over time.
• (Near) Crate-safe, but supervise first – While it’s marketed as crate-safe by some, always test it under supervision to be sure.

The KONG Extreme is an excellent choice for most aggressive chewers, but I’d recommend caution when leaving it unsupervised. If your dog tends to target weak points, you might want to consider an alternative toy.

Of all the KONG toys, the KONG Extreme is the toughest—built to last for your power chewer. Just make sure you get the right size!
Find the right one for your tough chewer on Amazon!

Now, for the (near) best safe dog toys for crates…

3. The Goughnuts MaXX Pro 50 Stick

Thousands of users give this toy a 5-star rating, and while I haven’t tested the Goughnuts MaXX Pro 50 Stick with our two, I can relate to the frustration of durable rubber toys that don’t hold up.

Some toys wear down so much that dogs end up eating bits of rubber—and we all know that’s a problem. In my defense, I thought they were spitting it out, not swallowing it. We stopped giving them cheap rubber rings after that, switching to nylon toys.

The Goughnuts MaXX Pro 50 Stick is a solid choice for extreme chewers. Made from tough rubber, it doesn’t have the weaknesses of toys with holes (like the KONG Extreme), and based on reviews from owners of strong chewers like Pit Bulls and Huskies, it stands up well. Dogs can leave marks on it, but it doesn’t break off into chunks that they can eat.

Several owners have mentioned they leave the Goughnuts MaXX Pro 50 Stick with their dogs in the crate overnight. It does seem safer than the KONG because it doesn’t have holes where dogs can start tearing it apart. The durable rubber stays intact, unlike some other toys.

That said, while it seems incredibly durable, I wouldn’t recommend leaving your dog alone with it right away. Watch how they interact with it first—do they chew calmly, or try to pull it apart with their paws and teeth?

And like the Benebone, keep an eye on the toy. Even the toughest ones can eventually break down, so be sure to replace it when needed.

Key Features:

• Solid rubber construction – No holes, eliminating weak points for aggressive chewers.
• Built for power chewers – Designed to withstand even the toughest jaws.
• Safety indicator – The inner layer turns bright yellow when it’s time to replace the toy.

Considerations:

• Not for unsupervised chewing starting out– Always monitor your dog, especially in the beginning.
• May not hold interest of food motivated chewers – Some dogs may lose interest if there’s no treat or stuffing to keep them engaged.

Set your dog’s crate training up for success with the crate-tested Goughnuts MaXX Pro 50 Stick!
Find the appropriate weight and colours on Amazon.

My Opinion

I’ve always been hesitant to leave any toy in the crate, fearing they might destroy every toy they get — like what happened with our KONG toy that wasn’t the right size. But after reading through reviews, I’ve seen several owners of active chewers, including young Pit Bulls and Huskies, who leave the Goughnuts MaXX Pro 50 Stick in the crate overnight or when they’re out.

Given its durable rubber construction, I’d be more comfortable with this than a Nylabone. While Nylabones are marketed as indestructible, they can be harder on your dog’s teeth. We gave our late Staffy a large indestructible ball, left him in the garden for a short while, and in that time, he’d ground his teeth down to the point his gums bled.

The tough rubber of the Goughnuts MaXX Pro seems like a gentler alternative on the doggy dental side, so a more balanced option for active chewers.

Bonus: Cheap Toys for Dogs That Are Heavy Chewers

Durable dog toys for power chewers can be pricey, and since no toy lasts forever, you’ll want to make them last as long as possible. One trick we’ve found helpful is keeping a toy basket stocked with a few affordable chews for our dogs to gnaw on as they please.

We use Hi-Craft Toyboy Chews, a UK-exclusive brand. I suspect the US equivalent is Nylabone toys—they’re similar in durability. Like Hi-Craft, Nylabones tend to be more expensive online, but you may find them cheaper in-store. For us, we grab ours from Home Bargains, a UK discount chain. In the US, you can check stores like Dollar General, Family Dollar, or Big Lots for similar deals.

These toys typically last a few months (often longer) partly because the dogs rotate them because they have enough of them in their basket. Bones, rings, and the Benobone wishbone. We have around 10 to choose from, so our dogs don’t chew on the same one every day.

The first toy they grab out of the crate is usually a Benebone, likely because of its challenging shape. When they’re bored, they’ll typically go for the Hi-Craft/Nylabone rings or bones, especially during the winter months when they’re indoors more often.

Final Thoughts

The best durable dog toys for aggressive chewers depends on your dog’s individual chewing habits. While no toy is truly indestructible, the ones listed above are among the toughest available—especially the Benebone.

If you go with the KONG Extreme, be sure to pick the right size and monitor your dog’s chewing style before letting them have it unsupervised. The Goughnuts MaXX Pro 50 Stick is another solid option, with its durable rubber construction and built-in safety indicator. Each of these toys has its strengths, but no chew toy lasts forever.

What are your go-to toys for power chewers? And just as importantly, which ones will you never buy again? Your experiences can help readers (myself included!) figure out which durable dog toys are worth it—and which ones to skip.

Drop a comment below and let me know which toys have (or haven’t) held up for your dog! (include the breed, too).